Fraud alert vs. credit freeze: which one do you need?
A fraud alert asks lenders to check it is really you. A freeze blocks access to your report. How each works, how long it lasts, and when to use both.
After a breach you will hear about two free tools: the fraud alert and the credit freeze. They sound alike but work very differently.
The short version
| Fraud alert | Credit freeze | |
|---|---|---|
| What it does | Asks lenders to take reasonable steps to confirm your identity before opening credit | Blocks most lenders from seeing your report at all |
| Cost | Free | Free |
| Where to place it | At one bureau, which must tell the other two | At each of the three bureaus |
| How long it lasts | 1 year (initial) or 7 years (extended) | Until you lift it |
| Effect on applying for credit | Possible extra call to confirm it is you | You lift it first, then apply |
| Strength | Moderate: depends on the lender checking | Strong for new credit |
Fraud alerts
There are three kinds:
- Initial fraud alert: anyone who thinks they may be at risk can place one, such as after a breach notice. It lasts one year and can be renewed.
- Extended fraud alert: for confirmed identity theft victims. It lasts seven years and requires an Identity Theft Report, which you can get at IdentityTheft.gov. It also removes you from prescreened credit offers for five years.
- Active duty alert: for service members deployed away from their usual station. It lasts one year.
To place one, contact any of Equifax, Experian or TransUnion. That bureau must pass the alert to the other two.
Credit freezes
A freeze locks your file at a bureau until you lift it. It is the stronger option because it does not rely on the lender noticing the alert. The trade-off is a small amount of planning: you lift the freeze before you apply for credit. See how to freeze your credit for each bureau’s steps.
Credit monitoring and “credit locks”
- Credit monitoring alerts you when something changes on your report, such as a new account or inquiry. It tells you about fraud after it starts; it does not block it. Breached companies often offer it free for a year or two.
- Credit locks are products some bureaus sell or include in paid plans. They work much like a freeze, but they are governed by a contract with the bureau rather than by the federal freeze law. The free freeze gives you the same core protection.
Which should you choose?
- SSN leaked in a breach: a credit freeze at all three bureaus.
- You are about to apply for a mortgage or car loan: an initial fraud alert now, a freeze after the loan closes.
- Someone already opened an account in your name: a freeze and an extended fraud alert. Follow our identity theft recovery guide.
- An older relative who rarely applies for credit: a freeze is simple to keep in place for years.
What to do now
- Decide which tool fits your situation using the list above.
- If you choose a freeze, place it at all three bureaus.
- If you choose a fraud alert, contact one bureau and note the date it expires.
- Check your free reports at AnnualCreditReport.com in a few months.
General information, not legal or financial advice. Sources: Federal Trade Commission (consumer.ftc.gov), Fair Credit Reporting Act.
Frequently asked questions about fraud alert vs credit freeze
Can I have a fraud alert and a credit freeze at the same time?
Yes. Many identity theft victims use both: the freeze blocks most new credit, and the alert asks any lender who does get access to confirm it is really you.
Does a fraud alert affect my credit score?
No. A fraud alert is a note on your file. It does not change your score or your existing accounts.